Skip to main content

Somebody at the table this year doesn't love your dog. Your dog doesn't love being shut away from you. Here's how to handle both, with a few tricks that aren't on the usual holiday checklist.

When I was a girl, a certain cousin used to come visit. She was about my age, and for the most part we got along. But she had a thing about dogs. She just didn’t like them. She’d never been bitten, snapped at, or snarled at. She’d never even been chased by the neighbor’s Yorkie, who was only ever out looking for a good time. I blame her parents.

Whatever the reason, every time my cousin-who-shall-remain-nameless came to stay, our dog Alice was banished to the carport storage room for the duration. For the record, Alice was the original designer dog: a Cockapoo, the odd one out in a litter of what looked like purebred Cocker Spaniels.

Every other day of the year, Alice had free rein. Of everything. So in my adolescent mind (which hasn’t changed much on this subject), the storage room was a tragedy. She was heartbroken. She’d have cried if she could. This was cruel. She would never forgive me. How could she possibly understand she wasn’t being punished?

It tortured me. So much that I usually spent the entire visit lying next to her on the storage room floor.

Well. I’m in charge now. I decide who stays and who goes.

And the cousin goes.

Well. I'm in charge now. I decide who stays and who goes. And the cousin goes.

brothers at a family holiday gathering. one holds a small white dog on the other's head

Okay, the Cousin Can Stay. Mostly.

Your momma raised you to make room at the table for everybody, even the one who flinches when the dog walks by. Fine.

But that carport storage room taught me something I still believe: there’s a difference between giving your dog space and putting your dog away. One is a kindness. The other feels like punishment, to the dog and to whoever’s lying on the floor next to her.

The usual advice stops at “put the dog in another room.” That’s where the real problems start: the dog who howls because she can hear you laughing, the guest who still feels ambushed, the allergy that shows up anyway. Here’s how to handle all of it.

Figure Out Which Kind of “Not a Dog Person” You’ve Got

Scared, allergic, and “I just don’t want paws on my good pants” need three different plans. Most hosts guess. Don’t. Send a text that makes it easy to answer honestly:

"

"Can't wait to see you! Quick question so I can set things up: is [Dog Name] a 'please keep away,' an 'allergies, sorry,' or a 'fine, just no jumping'? Any answer is a good answer."

Multiple choice is the trick. Nobody has to explain a fear or admit they’ve been dreading your dog for a week. They just pick one.

Then ask the question nobody asks: “Would you rather meet [Dog Name] or skip it entirely?” Some nervous people want a calm, controlled hello so they can stop worrying about it. Others want to never see the dog at all. Both are fine, but you can’t plan for either if you don’t ask.

Run a Dress Rehearsal

Alice’s real problem wasn’t the storage room. It was that the storage room only happened when the cousin came. The door closing meant something bad was going on out there.

So don’t let party day be the first time your dog spends an evening behind a door. Starting about a week out:

  • Practice short stints. Put your dog in their break room with something great to chew for 15 minutes while you’re home and making noise. Stretch it a little longer each day.
  • Make the room the good place. The best chew in the house only shows up in that room. Pretty soon your dog will trot in on their own.
  • Fake a party. Play a cooking show or a football game loud, ring the doorbell yourself, and have your partner chat in the kitchen. Boring rehearsal noise makes for a calmer real night.
  • Pick a cue. Use the same phrase every time, like “Go to your room, Biscuit.” On the big day, the routine feels familiar instead of suspicious.

Build a Break Room, Not a Banishment

A bed and a bowl in the back bedroom is a start. These are the details that make it work.

  • Choose the room by ear, not by convenience. Stand in each candidate room while someone talks at dinner volume in the kitchen. Pick the one where you can barely hear them. The closest room is often the worst choice.
  • Leave a T-shirt you’ve worn. Sleep in it the night before and tuck it into their bed. Your scent is the next best thing to you.
  • Wear them out with their nose. A slow, sniffy walk before guests arrive tires a dog out more than a brisk one. Let them smell every mailbox on the block.
  • Serve dinner in the room. Feed their meal in a puzzle toy or snuffle mat, and freeze a lick mat with plain pumpkin or plain yogurt to hand over right as the first guest arrives. Licking and sniffing are calming, and the doorbell starts to mean dessert.
  • Kill the doorbell. Tape a note to the front door: “Text when you’re here. Dog napping.” No ring, no knock, no frenzy. It also makes a cute porch sign.
  • Hang a sign on their door, too. Something like “VIP Lounge. Members Only.” It reminds guests not to wander in, and it’s a lot more fun than a closed door.
white fluffy dog on a bed with cozy blanket

When Your Dog Can’t Stand Knowing You’re in the Next Room

Some dogs are fine home alone all day. Shut a door while you’re still in the house, though, and they lose it. They can hear you. They can smell the turkey. Everybody they love is right there, laughing, and they’re stuck on the wrong side of the door. For a velcro dog, that’s worse than you being gone.

If that’s your dog, a closed door isn’t the answer. Try these instead.

  • Let them see you. Swap the door for a baby gate or an extra-tall pet gate so they have a sightline to you. Lots of dogs settle once they can see where you are.
  • Bring them into the room, on a job. Teach a “place” cue on a mat or bed in the corner of the living room, out of the traffic path. A short leash looped around a heavy piece of furniture keeps them parked. They’re with you, just not in anyone’s lap.
  • Make a dog-sitting rotation. Every party has a guest who’d rather hang out with the dog anyway. Recruit two or three of them for 20-minute shifts in the break room. Your dog gets company, and they get a break from the small talk.
  • Go in on a schedule, not on a whine. Visit every 45 minutes or so, but wait for a quiet moment before you open the door. Going in mid-howl teaches them that howling works.
  • Skip the pet camera pep talk. Talking to your dog through a camera speaker can backfire. Hearing your voice with no you attached is confusing, and it can wind up a dog who was starting to settle.
  • Do a quiet exit first. Before you put them up, sit with them in the room for five minutes, calm and boring. Then leave without a big goodbye. A dramatic farewell tells them something’s wrong.

If your dog drools, destroys doors, or tries to escape when separated from you, that’s more than holiday jitters. Talk to your vet a few weeks before the party. There are calming options and training plans, and some need time to start working.

For the Nervous Guest: Hand Them the Control

Fear is mostly about not knowing what the dog will do next. So give your guest the steering wheel.

  • Hand them a treat cup. If they’re open to meeting the dog, let them toss treats on the floor away from themselves. The dog moves away to eat, which is exactly what a nervous person wants. The dog learns this guest means snacks. The guest learns the dog follows the rules.
  • Teach them the dog’s tells. Tell your guest that a yawn, a lip lick, or a head turn means the dog is a little uneasy too. It’s oddly comforting to learn the dog is also just trying to get through dinner.
  • Give them the power seat. Seat them with their back to a wall and a view of the whole room, so nothing ever comes up behind them.
  • Put the dog in a bandana. Something like “Ask Before Petting” tells every guest the rules without you repeating them all night.
  • Never say “he’s friendly.” It’s the line every scared person has heard right before a dog jumped on them. Say “I’ve got him” instead, and mean it.
older woman holding white fluffy dog with younger woman to side

For the Allergic Guest: The Prep Nobody Thinks Of

Everybody remembers to vacuum. These are the steps that get missed.

  • Bathe the dog a day or two before, not the morning of. A bath can cut down on dander for a short while, and a dog who’s still damp when guests walk in is its own problem.
  • Brush outside. Give them a good brushing in the yard the morning of, so the loose hair stays out there.
  • Change the air filter. A fresh HVAC filter and an air purifier running in the main room do more than a quick vacuum.
  • Rethink the coat pile. Don’t toss coats on the bed your dog naps on. Clear a closet or set out a rack the dog never touches.
  • Stock the guest bathroom. A lint roller, a spare box of tissues, and a note that says “Help yourself” spare your guest from having to ask.
  • Dog-proof one chair. Put a fresh slipcover or washed throw on the seat they’ll use, and keep the dog off it for a few days ahead.
  • Wash your hands after petting. And ask dog-loving guests to do the same before they hug your allergic friend.

If the allergy is serious, keeping your dog in their break room for most of the visit is the kind call for everybody. Just make it a room with a lamp on, not the carport.

Everybody Gets a Seat

I don’t know if Alice ever forgave my cousin. I’m not sure I have. But I know she didn’t need to spend those visits in the dark, wondering what she’d done wrong.

Your guest gets a comfortable chair and a plate they don’t have to guard. Your dog gets a room that smells like you, a frozen lick mat, and a visit between courses. Nobody ends up on the storage room floor.

Unless it’s the cousin. I’m still in charge.

Meet The Author

martha wanstrath, creative director and marketing director for darling dog with her dog, winnie

Martha is Darling Dog’s Creative & Marketing Director and a lifelong Southerner, raised in Montgomery, AL and now dividing her time between Dallas, TX and Fayetteville, AR. She’s a dog nut through and through, and her foster fail, Birdie, is the toughest editor she’s ever had.